The Beasts: a tense tale of nightmare neighbours in windswept Galicia
Bad-neighbour stories in film often fall into one of two categories. There's the mordant comedy of mundane conflict, as ordinary people chip away at each other in ways we recognise with a wince. And there's more extreme psychodrama, as one party gradually realises something is very wrong indeed with the others next door – or, if you will, across their rear window.
In Rodrigo Sorogoyen's nippy, nerve-raddled The Beasts, however, the one mode of story spills over into the other, so insidiously that we don't realise the extent of the neighbour danger until it's too late – and the terms of dispute must be drawn anew. And while the close-quarters geography of most neighbour stories tend to dictate a certain homogeneity between otherwise opposed households, this terrific study of turf wars in rural Galicia folds a world of thorny social politics – working-class versus bourgeois, immigrant versus indigenous, community versus individual – into the increasingly ugly feud at its core. Sympathies aren't apportioned as tidily as you'd expect. Everybody emerges a loser.
Tucked in Spain's northwesternmost reaches, perched above Portugal and hemmed in by water on two sides, the rural region of Galicia has a literally cornered, insular quality conducive to the fractiousness of Sorogoyen's slow-burning narrative. It's a hilly, knobbly landscape, shot by cinematographer Alex de Pablo in rained-on earth tones that look consistently autumnal even as the story cycles through seasons, and then years. You might wonder why French couple Antoine (Denis Ménochet) and Olga (Marina Foïs), middle-aged and middle-class, have settled on this part of Spain to build a new life for themselves; many of the weary, impoverished residents in their chosen village certainly do.
But Antoine and Olga are drawn to challenge. Well educated and ecologically conscious, they see themselves as an asset to an underprivileged environment, as they renew and renovate a series of derelict properties, and ethically farm organic vegetables to hawk at local markets. Unsurprisingly, most of the local Galicians don't take quite such a romantic view, and their two nearest neighbours are especially wary. Surly livestock farmer Xan (a superb Luis Zahera) and his mentally impaired brother Loren (Diego Anido) scrape together a living on the scrubby, long-owned family farmstead they share with their elderly mother. The brothers don't share the French couple's idealistic regard for a landscape that has never treated them especially kindly; when a team of wind-farm developers offers to buy them out, they're all too happy to take the money and start a new, urban life for themselves far from the mountain. But the deal hinges on the whole village agreeing to sell; the outsiders, who need the money least, are the holdouts.
Across a measured but never sluggish 137-minute runtime, Sorogoyen and co-writer Isabel Peña mark escalating tensions in stages as slow but inexorable as changes of weather. As an impasse presents itself, the local menfolk first make their displeasure known through passive-aggressive exchanges with Antoine at the village bar. Less passively, they then resort to poisoning the couple's water supply. It's not the most drastic measure they'll take.
Guy Lodge, Sight and Sound, 23 March 2023
Director
Rodrigo Sorogoyen
Date of release
2023
Running time
137 min
Rating
15
Country of origin
Spain, France
Language
French/Galician/Spanish with English subtitles